Shawn Lazar
Associate Editor
I. INTRODUCTION
David W. Cloud is a Fundamental Baptist missionary, writer, and publisher. His Way of Life Literature is well-known in Fundamentalist circles and defends many conservative positions with which readers of JOTGES would agree. Cloud has even explicitly written against Lordship Salvation. But how consistent is he in rejecting it?
II. FREE GRACE FRIENDLY POSITIONS
Cloud takes several positions that would naturally align him with Free Grace Theology. In this section, I list six such positions.
A. Cloud Is a Dispensationalist
In an article entitled, âStudy the Bible Dispensationally,â1 Cloud affirms that a âconsistent application of the literal method of interpretation will result in a dispensational theology.â2 He warns against Covenant Theology, Progressive Dispensationalism, and Hyper Dispensationalism. Cloud seems to favor Dispensationalism as taught by Scofield and Charles Ryrie without requiring complete adherence to any one system.3
B. Cloud Affirms Faith Alone
Cloud affirms that we are saved by faith alone, not by works. For example, in the Way of Life Encyclopedia of the Bible & Christianity, Cloud writes: âSalvation is through faith ALONE and grace ALONE, not by any mixture of grace and law, faith and works (Ro. 4:13-16; 11:6).â4 It is difficult to miss the emphasis on âalone.â Cloud then writes a paragraph with which many JOTGES readers would agree:
Faith alone is the door into Godâs wonderful salvation. Having been forgiven and blessed with eternal blessings in Christ, we serve God with a thankful heartânot in order to be saved or in order to perfect our salvation, but because we have been saved. We are not saved by works; we are saved unto works (Ep. 2:8-10; Titus 3:4-8).5
Again, we see the emphasis on âfaith alone.â And Cloud is intent on clarifying that we do good works because we have been saved by faith alone, not to be saved. This is strongly in keeping with Free Grace Theology. However, as we will see in later sections, Cloud contradicts himself on this point.
C. Cloud Defends Easy Believism in Principle
Cloud offers qualified support for âeasy believism.â Many people reject the term outright. Not Cloud. He defendsâat least in principleâthe idea that salvation is both easy and by believing:
There is an evangelistic methodology in Christian circles today which is a plague to sound gospel preaching. Some call this âeasy believism,â but I donât like that term. Belief is exactly what God requires for salvation. âFor by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boastâ (Eph. 2:8-9). âFor God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting lifeâ (Jn. 3:16). Salvation is received by believing. Further, God has made it easy to do. A child can trust Christ and be saved; a weak-minded person can trust Christ and be saved. Salvation is not difficult, except in the sense that the sinner has to humble himself and repent (emphasis his).6
The real problem, Cloud believes, is not easy believism per se, but what he calls âquick prayerism.â This is the method of evangelism that claims someone has been saved after saying a sinnerâs prayer.7
D. Cloud Affirms Eternal Security
Cloud believes in eternal security. For example, in his Believerâs Bible Dictionary, he defends the eternality of salvation, using arguments that will be familiar to Free Grace advocates:
How can we be sure that the believer is eternally secure? (1) Because of the terms used to describe salvation: âeternal lifeâ (Jn. 3:16; 1 Jn 5:11); âfull assuranceâ (Heb. 6:11; Col. 2:2); âstrong consolationâ (Heb. 6:18); âhopeâŚsure and steadfastâ (Heb. 6:19).8
How do we know these blessings cannot be lost? (1) The blessings of salvation cannot be lost because of the nature of salvation: Salvation is eternal (Jn. 3:16, 36); salvation is a present possession (Ro. 5:1; 1 Pe. 2:24-25); salvation is by imputation and substitution (Ep. 1:3 âin Christâ; Ro. 6:7; Col. 2:10; 3:1-4, 12); salvation is not of human merit; it is a free gift of grace which cannot be mixed with worksâŚ9
Cloud believes that eternal security is part of the very meaning of life being âeternal.â Note especially the last sentence in which Cloud affirms that salvation is a free gift âwhich cannot be mixed with works.â This is consistent with his insistence that salvation is by faith âalone,â that is, that it excludes works.
E. Cloud Distinguishes Between Relationship and Fellowship
Cloud distinguishes between a believerâs eternal relationship with God and his conditional fellowship with God. For example, in commenting on 1 John, he explains,
Here the Lord makes a plain distinction between relationship and fellowship. The theme of 1 John is found in 1:3. The theme is fellowship, not relationship. It is written to those who have established a relationship with God as children through faith in Christ.10
Your relationship with God is established through faith. But fellowship is established on other conditions. Cloud sees this distinction also taught in Johnâs Gospel:
In John 1-12 the focus is on the unsaved and the main message is âbelieve on the Lord Jesus Christâ (Jn. 1:7, 12; 3:15-16, 18; 4:39; 5:24; 6:35, 47; 7:38; 8:24; 9:35; 10:38; 11:26). When the unsaved asked about doing the works of God, Christ replied, âThis is the work of God, that ye believe on him whom he hath sentâ (Jn. 6:29). Faith in Christ is the only work God will accept from the unsaved.11
Notice that Cloud takes John 6:29 as Jesus teaching that faith, not works, is necessary for salvation. That is the only requirement from the unsaved. Free Grace advocates would heartily agree.
Cloud goes on to notice a change in the theme of Johnâs Gospel when Jesus begins to teach in the Upper Room:
This change in theme of Johnâs Gospel illustrates the difference between relationship and fellowship. Faith is the requirement for eternal relationship; obedience is the requirement for daily fellowship. Faith is the way to become a child of God; obedience is the way to walk in fellowship with the Father.12
While the relationship is by faith alone, the fellowship is by obedience. Once again, Free Grace advocates would strongly agree with this theological distinction. Knowing the difference between our position and our condition is key to avoiding the danger of Lordship Salvation and to putting works in their proper doctrinal âplace.â
F. Cloud Rejects Both Calvinism and Arminianism
Cloud rejects both Calvinism and Arminianism. He explains why he rejects Calvinism in his book The Calvinism Debate.13 To summarize: âIf isolated and interpreted through Calvinistic lenses, there are verses that seem to teach Calvinism, but when Scripture is taken as a whole it crumbles.â14 He does not see it established by Scripture.
However, that does not mean Cloud identifies as an Arminian. In fact, he explicitly rejects both Calvinism and Arminianism:
James White, author of âThe Truth about the King James Bible Controversyâ and âThe Potterâs Freedomâ and several other books, wrote to me in about the year 1999 and challenged me to a public debate. He urged me to âdefend Arminianism.â That is a strange notion, I donât follow Arminianism and I donât care anything about Arminianism. I have studied the theology of James Arminius some and I find errors in it just as I have found errors in John Calvinâs theology. Though I do believe that Arminius was closer to the truth than Calvin, this does not mean that I have any intention to âdefend Arminianism.â White has the idea that is so typical among Calvinists that if a man is not a Calvinist, he is surely an Arminian.15
Hence, without giving a name for his theology, Cloud does not consider himself either a Calvinist or an Arminian.
G. Summary
All of these positions would seem to put Cloud close to the Free Grace camp. His Dispensationalism, emphasis on faith alone, the conditional nature of spiritual maturity, the possibility of carnality, and the doctrine of eternal security and rejection of both Calvinism and Arminianism would make it seem he is very Free Grace-friendly. That impression is made all the stronger by Cloudâs explicit rejection of Lordship Salvation.
III. CLOUD REJECTS LORDSHIP SALVATION
David Cloud rejects Lordship Salvation by name in two articles, âRepentance and Lordship Salvation,â16 and âRepentance and Lordship Salvation Revisited.â17 Those articles show he is aware that Lordship Salvation amounts to a gospel of works salvation.
A. Lordship Salvation Is Salvation by Works
We saw that Cloud affirms that salvation is by faith âalone.â It comes as little surprise, then, that Cloud understands that the evangelistic demand to make Christ Lord of your life is a covert form of salvation by works:
We do not support any idea of âLordship Salvationâ that teaches that an individual must make Jesus Christ Lord of every area of his life before he can be saved. Salvation does not produce perfect obedience nor does it require perfect understanding of theology. A genuinely born again Christian can be carnal. The Bible plainly teaches this (1 Corinthians 3).
To require that a sinner make Jesus Christ Lord of every area of his life is an impossibility and would be the greatest form of works salvation ever devised. This false doctrine is taught by some independent Baptists, but we do not support it. It is a very dangerous doctrine that causes people to look inside themselves and to examine their experience rather than to look solely upon the Lord Jesus Christ and to trust solely upon His shed blood.18
Cloud makes several excellent statements in these two paragraphs. For example, JOTGES readers will appreciate how Cloud recognizes that some believers can be âcarnal.â That ties in with Cloudâs teaching that fellowship with God is conditional. If you can be out of fellowship with God, you can be carnal.
Cloud is also correct to criticize turning inward, presumably to our works, for assurance of salvation, instead of looking âsolely upon the Lord Jesus Christ.â Indeed, the only object of saving faith and assurance is Jesusâ promise of eternal life.
However, notice that Cloud hedges his criticism of Lordship Salvation. He does not say that demanding any level of obedience to Christ for salvation is wrong. Although he denies supporting âany ideaâ of Lordship Salvation, he only rejects the claim that you must make Jesus Lord âof every areaâ of life, or that you must have âperfect obedienceâ to be saved. Does that mean you must make Jesus Lord of some areas of your life, or that you must have some level of obedience to Christ to be saved?
B. Lordship Salvation Confuses Justification and Sanctification
Cloud correctly recognizes the possibility that a born-again person can be carnal. He also draws a distinction between justification and sanctification, or between our standing and our state. As Cloud explains, confusing the two can lead to salvation by works:
To preach a âlordship salvationâ that requires that sinners make Jesus Christ absolute Lord of every area of their lives in order to be saved is to confuse position and practice, justification and sanctification. This is similar to the error made by many Pentecostals and Charismatics who believe the child of God can lose his salvation. An excellent testimony about the danger of this false teaching is in the book âHoliness: The False and the Trueâ by the late Harry A. Ironside (Loizeaux).19
Although it is heartening to read Cloud reject Lordship Salvation, again, note Cloudâs choice of language. He rejects the call to make Jesus âabsoluteâ Lord of âevery areaâ of life. Why add those qualifications? What about more modest Lordship claims? Would Cloud agree that Jesus must be the Lord of âsomeâ areas of your life to be saved? Does that not also involve teaching salvation by works?
IV. CLOUDâS INCONSISTENT POSITION ON REPENTANCE
Unfortunately, Cloudâs doctrine of salvation is inconsistent. Ultimately, despite denying Lordship Salvation, Cloud makes works a condition of salvation. For example, that is shown in his doctrine of repentance.
Earlier, we quoted Cloud explicitly saying that faith alone is the sole condition of salvation. Is Cloud consistent in that affirmation? It turns out he is not. He contradicts himself by heavily emphasizing that repentance is a condition for salvation.
A. What Repentance Is Not
In his article on âBiblical Repentanceâ and elsewhere, Cloud has explained what repentance is not. For example, it is not a synonym for faith: âBible preachers proclaimed repentance, and if faith is the same as repentance as some claim, this would make no sense.â20
Nor is it a mere change of mind. In his comments condemning what he calls âquick prayerism,â Cloud thinks it is wrong to redefine repentance in that way. He says: âQuick Prayerism is an evangelistic methodology that is quick to get people to pray a sinnerâs prayer after a shallow gospel presentation and usually without any hint of the necessity of repentance (or redefining repentance to be the same as faith or to be a mere âchange of mindâ).â21
Cloud lists a number of other things that are not equivalent to repentance: it is more than remorse, confession, acknowledgment of sin, or changing from unbelief to belief.22
So what is repentance, according to Cloud?
B. Cloudâs Definition of Repentance
According to Cloud, repentance is a change of mind that leads to a change of life:
Biblical repentance as preached by John the Baptist, the Lord Jesus Christ, and the apostles, is a change of mind toward God and sin that results in a change of life. It is a Spirit-wrought change of mind that leads to a change of life. It is not a change of life. That would be works salvation. It is a radical, Spirit-wrought change of mind toward sin and God, such a dramatic change that it changes oneâs actions.23
Cloud emphasizes that genuine repentance results in a changed life:
It is not a change of life; it is a change of mind so radical that it results in a change of life. It means to turn around and go in a different direction. It means to lay down your arms and to surrender to God, to stop being at enmity against Him. I believe this is exactly what the Bible teaches about repentance, and I have shown this in the original article on Repentance, but nowhere have I said that repentance means to repent of all your sin or to turn away from all of your sin. That would be a works salvation, which is a false gospel.24
Here again, Cloud says that repentance is a change of mind that results in a radical change of life. And he again emphasizes the words âresults in.â Why? He adds âresults inâ because if repentance were itself a changed life involving works, and if repentance were a condition of salvation, âThat would be works salvation.â
You can also sense Cloudâs hesitancy with his definition when he clarifies that the change is not so radical that it means you repent or turn away from âall your sin.â He admits that, too, would be a âfalse gospel.â Elsewhere he repeats: âRepentance is not turning from all sin in the sense of some sort of sinless perfection; it is a change of mind toward sin so that the sinner no longer intends to walk in rebellion against God.â25
This definition creates a tension (or outright contradiction) in his theology. Cloud thinks he can avoid teaching works salvation if he qualifies his definition of repentance with the words âresults in.â If it only results in doing good works, but is not itself good works, then making repentance a condition of salvation may not be a form of salvation by works.
Elsewhere Cloud says: âThe fact that God requires that we turn from sin does not mean that salvation is by works. We know that the works are the fruit of genuine salvation, not the cause of it.â26 If Cloud consistently distinguished between repentance and the works that follow repentance, he could avoid the charge of works salvation. But, as he himself says, God requires that we turn from sin. If turning from sin is required, then it is a condition of salvation.
C. Repentance Means Doing Works
In the Believerâs Bible Dictionary, Cloud gives several illustrations of what it means to repent. Notice his language. Cloud does not say that repentance results in works. He will say âRepentance isâŚâ and then names a work:
1. Repentance is the Prodigal Son coming to right thinking, confessing his sin against God and his father, and returning home (Lk. 15:17-20).
2. Repentance is the Thessalonians turning to God from idols to serve the living and true God (1 Th. 1:9).
3. Repentance is Zacchaeus turning from corruption to uprightness (Lk. 19:8-9).
4. Repentance is Nebuchadnezzar humbling himself before God (Da. 4:37).
5. Repentance is the Philippian jailer turning to Jesus Christ and becoming a kind of helper of Christians (Acts 16:33-34).
6. Repentance is the Christ-rejecting Jews at Pentecost turning to Christ and continuing in obedience (Acts 2:38-42).27
In this list, Cloud explicitly identifies repentance with doing works. This contradicts those places where he tries to distinguish the two, such as: âTo say that repentance results in works is not the same as saying that repentance is works.â28 So why, in the list above, does Cloud explicitly say that repentance âisâ this or that work? His doctrine of repentance is inconsistent at this point. For Cloud, repentance is both a work and results in works.
D. Repentance Is Necessary for Salvation
Cloud believes that repentance is necessary for salvation. This directly contradicts his claims that salvation is by faith alone. Salvation cannot be by faith alone if it is also by repentance. So what does Cloud believeâis salvation by faith alone, or by faith plus repentance that results in a changed life? You can cite passages for both ideas. We already quoted Cloud defending faith alone. But here he criticizes evangelism that does not mention the co-condition of repentance: âThe typical soul-winning plan doesnât even hint at repentance, that there is going to be a change of direction, a submission to God.â29
Why would that be a problem? Because according to Cloud, without repentance, there is no salvation:
Salvation demands repentance (Lk 13:3-5; Ac. 2:38-42; 17:30-31). Repentance means a change of mind resulting in a change of life (2 Cor. 7:8-11). The person who has never changed his mind about God, sin, Christ, the Bible, etc., and who has never shown evidence of this in his life, has never repented and is not saved.30
Clearly, there is a contradiction in this theology.
Likewise, recall that when Cloud defended easy believism, he qualified his statement with these words: âSalvation is not difficult, except in the sense that the sinner has to humble himself and repent.â31 Repentance is here made part of the condition of salvation (does that make humbling yourself a third co-condition for salvation or one of the works of repentance?). And Cloud implies it is difficult, in the sense you must be humbled and repent.
Indeed, Cloud says that salvation itself is described as coming to repentance:
Salvation is referred to as coming to repentance with no mention of faith in Matthew 9:13; 11:20-21; 21:32; Mark 1:4; 2:17; 6:12; Luke 15:7; 24:47; Acts 2:38; 3:19; 5:31; 11:18; 26:20; 2 Corinthians 7:10; 1 Thessalonians 1:9; 2 Timothy 2:25; and 2 Peter 3:9.32
E. Why This Ends in Denying Faith Alone
Does Cloud evade the charge of denying salvation by faith alone? No, he does not.
First, if salvation is by faith plus repentance, and repentance is not a synonym for faith, then salvation is not by faith alone. It is by faith plus repentance. Cloud contradicts himself.
Second, if you are only saved by repentance that results in works, and not by one without works, then your salvation depends upon works. Cloud is aware of that implication and seeks to avoid the charge of teaching salvation by works by saying, ânowhere have I said that repentance means to repent of all your sin or to turn away from all of your sin. That would be a works salvation, which is a false gospel.â33 He seems to think that so long as you do not require repentance from all sins, you avoid works salvation. But according to the Apostle Paul, adding any amount of works to the saving message turns it into another gospel (Gal 1:6-9). In other words, requiring people to repent of any amount of sin as a condition of salvation would be works salvation. Even though Cloud does not require repentance from all sin, he does require repentance from some.34 Hence, he teaches salvation by works.
V. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN FALSE FAITH AND GENUINE FAITH
Cloudâs view of the relationship between salvation, faith, and repentance is involved in another contradiction. On the one hand, as we have seen, he strongly distinguishes between faith and repentance. However, there are other places where he explicitly redefines faith to include repentance within it. That is seen in his distinction between false faith and saving faith.
A. True Faith Includes Repentance
Cloud is evidently aware of Free Grace claims that it is significant that the only self-identified evangelistic book in the Bible, the Gospel of John, omits the word repentance: âSome men say that it is not necessary to preach repentance since we donât see it in John 3:16 and Acts 16:31âŚâ35 However, Cloud is not persuaded. Why not? Because he believes repentance is implied in the very concept of saving faith itself:
The reason why verses such as John 3:16 and Acts 16:31 donât mention repentance is that proper saving faith includes repentance and proper repentance includes faith…By comparing Scripture with Scripture (rather than isolating Scripture, which is the method used by false teachers), I conclude that saving faith includes repentance. 36
Repentance is implied in the concept of faith, but Cloud earlier denied that it is a synonym for faith. Redefining faith to include repentance that results in a changed life compromises the doctrine of justification at the root. It smuggles works into the definition of faith itself. But if repentance is not a synonym for faith, why does Cloud think it is implied by the concept of faith? This is another contradiction.
B. Saving Faith Produces Good Works
Cloud says that saving faith produces good works. If it does not, it is not saving: â(4) Saving faith always produces good works (Ep 2:8-10; He 11:4, 7, 8; Ja 2:14-26). If a person claims to have faith in Christ, but his life does not reflect the works of Christ, that person does not have saving faith.â37
Here is more evidence that Cloud teaches salvation by works. If you are only saved by a faith that produces good works, and not saved by faith that does not produce good works, then works are part of the condition of salvation. This is another form of salvation by works. It denies that we are saved by faith alone. That is a contradiction in Cloudâs theology.
VI. CONCLUSION
There is much to admire in David Cloudâs theology. This writer has benefited from his books and articles. Cloud takes several very strong positions for salvation by faith alone and against Lordship Salvation. Sadly, he then contradicts those positions with his doctrines of repentance and faith, both of which make salvation depend upon changing your behavior and doing good works. Cloudâs soteriology is inconsistent. He ought to resolve the inconsistency by affirming faith aloneâperiod. He should go back to his distinction between relationship and fellowship and see that repentance is a fellowship issue, not a relationship one.38 In sum, Cloud should repent of his view of repentance.
____________________
1 https://www.wayoflife.org/database/study_bible_dispensationally.html.
2 Ibid.
3 Ibid.
4 Emphasis his. David W. Cloud, Way of Life Encyclopedia of the Bible & Christianity, 6th ed. (Port Huron, MI: Way of Life Literature, 2016), 573.
5 Ibid.
6 David W. Cloud, âRepentance and Lordship Salvation Revisited.â See https://www.wayoflife.org/database/repentancerevisited.html. Accessed Oct. 29, 2018.
7 Ibid.; cf. David Cloud, The Hyles Effect: A Spreading Blight (Port Huron, MI: Way of Life, 2014), 75.
8 David W. Cloud, Believerâs Bible Dictionary (Port Huron, MI: Way of Life, 2015), 93.
9 Ibid., 94
10 Cloud, Encyclopedia, 574.
11 Ibid.
12 Ibid.
13 David W. Cloud, The Calvinism Debate (Port Huron, MI: Way of Life Literature, 2006, 2013).
14 Ibid., 15.
15 Ibid., 12.
16 David Cloud, âRepentance and Lordship Salvation.â See https://www.wayoflife.org/database/repentance_lordship_salvation.html. Accessed Nov. 16, 2018.
17 David Cloud, âRepentance Revisited.â See https://www.wayoflife.org/database/repentancerevisited.html. Accessed Nov. 16, 2018.
18 Cloud, âRepentance and Lordship Salvation.â
19 Cloud, âRepentance and Lordship Salvation.â
20 Cloud, Bible Dictionary, 273.
21 Cloud, Hyles, 75.
22 David Cloud, âBiblical Repentance.â See https://www.wayoflife.org/database/biblical_repentance.html. Accessed Nov. 16, 2018.
23 Ibid.
24 Cloud, âRepentance Revisited,â emphasis added.
25 Cloud, âBiblical Repentance,â emphasis added.
26 Ibid., emphasis added.
27 Cloud, Believerâs Bible Dictionary, 275.
28 Cloud, âBiblical Repentance.â
29 Cloud, Calvinism, 52. By contrast, the Gospel of John, the only self-described evangelistic book in the Bible, does not mention repentance. Neither do the Books of Romans or Galatians.
30 Cloud, Dictionary, 94. But I disagree that his proof-texts show that repentance is necessary to be born again. Luke 13:3-5 and Acts 2:38-42 are about being saved from the temporal judgment of AD 70, not about being born again. If you want to avoid the natural and divine consequences of sin in this life, you must repent of them. If you want to avoid dying of a drug overdose, you should repent of taking drugs. If you want to avoid divorce, repent of adultery. If you want to avoid being shot to death, repent of robbing stores. Temporal salvation does depend on repentance. But that does not prove you must repent in order to be born again. If eternal salvation demands repentance, how much repentance must you do and for how long before you are born again? Making behavior change a condition of salvation obscures the truth that salvation happens in a moment, through a single act of faith in Christ for eternal life, totally apart from works. Careful readers should consider whether Cloudâs proof-texts address eternal salvation, or some other type of deliverance.
31 Cloud, âRepentance and Lordship Salvation Revisited,â emphasis added.
32 David W. Cloud, âWhy Doesnât John 3:16 and Acts 16:31 Mention Repentance?â See https://www.wayoflife.org/database/john316repentance.html. Accessed Oct. 29, 2018. Readers ought to look up each of those passages and ask what kind of salvation is discussed in each passage (e.g., is it earthly or eternal?). While it is true that repentance featured prominently in Jesusâ preaching and in NT teaching, that is not enough to show it is a co-condition for being born again. What is repentance for? Is it for Israel to receive the kingdom? Is it preparatory to faith? Is it for restoration of fellowship with God? Is it to avoid temporal discipline and destruction? Simply quoting verses that have the word repentance does not show that it is a synonym for faith, part of faith, or a condition for being born again.
33 Cloud, âRepentance Revisited.â
34 Of course, this also makes assurance of salvation impossible. How could anyone possibly know if he had turned from enough sins to be born again? He cannot.
35 Cloud, âWhy Doesnât John 3:16 and Acts 16:31 Mention Repentance?â
36 Ibid.
37 Cloud, Bible Dictionary, 94-95.
38 See Zane C. Hodges, Harmony with God: A Fresh Look at Repentance (Dallas, TX: Redencion Viva, 2001).
